Fit interviewCase interview

Consulting Fit Interview: How to Prepare and Avoid Common Mistakes

Published: 6 min read
In short

A consulting fit interview tests whether you fit the firm, and it runs through the whole interview, including the case. Start preparing at least 3-4 weeks ahead: collect stories that show the firm's key qualities, tell them in the CAR structure (complication, actions, results), show your personal contribution, and prepare an answer on weaknesses and substantive questions for the interviewer.

A consulting fit interview (also called a behavioral interview) tests whether you fit the firm as a professional people want to work with and can always rely on. You need to prepare for it systematically and in advance, at least 3-4 weeks ahead: collect stories from your experience, practice the structure of telling them and prepare answers to awkward questions.

Fit is one of the most underestimated parts of preparing for a consulting interview. Many people think the main thing is to "solve cases" and the rest will take care of itself. In practice it works differently: even a perfect solution to a business problem does not make up for the poor impression left by a weak fit part. In my experience, about 40% of the overall interview assessment now comes from fit.

When is fit assessed in a consulting interview?

Fit is assessed throughout the entire interview. The first part, where you answer questions about yourself, is only the beginning. During the case, the interviewer also watches how you reason, keep your structure, handle stress and interact with them. So the way you solve a case is also part of your fit.

How do you prepare for a consulting fit interview?

To show that you fit, prepare in five areas.

Collect stories that match the firm's key qualities

Pick stories from your experience that demonstrate exactly the qualities the firm names as most important when it selects candidates. It helps to have a set of stories of different types: from Personal Impact to a story about a failure (a fuck-up story).

Tell your stories in the CAR structure

Use a clear structure so that your story is clear and convincing. For example, the CAR format:

C (complication): the complication → A (actions): your actions → R (results): the result

A template that makes it easy to write down each story while you prepare:

"Complication: in [project or situation], [problem] came up. My actions: I [what you personally did]. Result: [what it led to, in numbers if you have them]."

Stories written down with this template are easy to check for two common mistakes: a vague personal contribution and too much context. More on both below.

Get used to thinking out loud

Practice reasoning out loud, in a structured way and without panic, even under uncertainty. The interviewer sees this skill both in the fit part and in the case.

Learn to listen and ask clarifying questions

The ability to listen and clarify is an important soft skill that people often overlook when they prepare. It is better to ask again and clarify the question than to confidently answer a question you were not asked.

Study each firm's culture

McKinsey, BCG and Bain differ from each other. Some things matter to all of them, but there are differences in the details. Prepare your stories and wording with the firm you are applying to in mind.

What mistakes do candidates make when preparing for a fit interview?

Here are five mistakes in fit preparation and how to avoid them.

Mistake 1. Expecting to prepare in a couple of days

Preparing for a fit interview takes self-reflection, and cramming the night before cannot replace it. Start at least 3-4 weeks ahead so you have time to recall your stories, choose the best ones and rehearse them.

Mistake 2. Not describing your contribution to the result

Phrases like "we did a project" do not work. The interviewer needs to understand your personal contribution: which decisions you made yourself and what they led to. Say "I" when you describe your actions.

Mistake 3. Too long an introduction to the context

The most important part of a story is what you did and what results you achieved. Do not spend time immersing the interviewer in context unless it is critical for understanding your contribution. Practice getting your point across concisely.

Mistake 4. No answer about your weaknesses

If you have not prepared an answer to the question about your weaknesses, you are not ready for the interview. Come up with an honest example that is still safe for consulting and shows that you can change. I covered how to answer this and other awkward questions in Tricky Interview Questions.

Mistake 5. No deep questions for the interviewer

Generic questions you could ask anywhere, like "What projects is the company working on right now?", do not work. Prepare substantive, company-specific questions and explain why exactly they interest you. I collected examples in What Questions to Ask the Interviewer.

What does a strong fit show in the end?

Fit shows how well you can present yourself as a professional people want to work with and can always rely on. A set of qualities like "smart" and "hard-working" does not prove this on its own: you need stories, structure and the right behavior throughout the interview.

A good place to start is the answer to the first question of the fit part: I described how to build it in How to Answer "Tell Me About Yourself". You can practice fit together with cases in case interview coaching.

FAQ

What is a fit interview in consulting?

A fit interview (behavioral interview) tests whether you fit the firm: your qualities, your motivation and how you work with people. You answer questions about yourself and tell stories from your experience. But fit is also assessed during the case: the interviewer watches how you reason, keep your structure, handle stress and communicate with them.

How much does the fit interview matter in consulting?

In my experience, about 40% of the overall interview assessment now comes from fit. Even a perfect case solution does not make up for the poor impression left by a weak fit part. So prepare fit as systematically as cases: with stories, a structure for telling them, rehearsals and answers to awkward questions.

How long does it take to prepare for a consulting fit interview?

Start at least 3-4 weeks ahead. Preparing for a fit interview takes self-reflection: you need to recall stories from your experience, choose the ones that show the qualities the firm values most, arrange them in the CAR structure and rehearse them. You cannot do this kind of work in a couple of days before the interview.

How do I answer "What are your weaknesses?" in a consulting fit interview?

Prepare this answer in advance: if you have not prepared it, you are not ready for the interview. Name an honest example of a weakness that is still safe for consulting and show that you can change: what you are already doing to fix it. Saying "I have no weaknesses" or passing off a strength as a weakness sounds implausible.

What is the CAR structure for a fit interview?

CAR is a structure for telling a story from your experience. C (complication): what complication came up. A (actions): what you personally did. R (results): what result it led to. The structure helps make your story clear and convincing, and the focus on actions and results keeps you from getting lost in describing the context.

Related videos

Mock interview with detailed feedback: operations case, mining industry

A full mock interview with one of my students: fit questions, an operations case and detailed feedback at the end. This is what my sessions look like.

Based on posts in the Telegram channel «Игра на Повышение» (in Russian)
Evgenii Lugachev
Evgenii Lugachev

Career coach and case interview coach. I help people choose a career path, get offers and grow at work.

About

Let's talk about your situation

Send me a couple of lines on Telegram: where you are now and where you want to get. I reply personally and suggest the format that fits you.